Thursday, July 18, 2013

Tenth Interview – On Pianism, Pianos, Practise & Pianists


A subject of this interview is pianism. Should I repeat the definition?
Sure.
OK, we agreed that pianism was a noun, being either, the artistry and technique of a pianist, or the performance by a pianist as in an evening of first-rate pianism.
Yes, and ... 
... the practise and study of the piano and its music.
Bravo! Laughs
All right, well we were discussing before many subjects that relate to pianism focusing on the choice of a piano, the choice of a repertoire, the abilities of the player, the kinds of practise sessions, with some practical observations. What are these like for you right now?
Well, laughs the choice of a piano was certainly on my mind as I went back down to New York the first of last November [2012] and earlier this last Spring.
How many stores did you see during these trips?
Only two, Faust Harrison and Beethoven's.
Well?
Faust Harrison had some fabulous pianos, they always do. In November, they had a “perfect,” and I mean it, Steinway C, which is hands down my favourite of all Steinway's scale designs. Now, I know what I'm going to say about pianos this time is informed by that great experience I had there with Sara Faust conducting an impromptu master class / piano lesson. It laid bare the conditions under which a pianist, at whatever level, and we'll discuss that a little too, should choose one's piano, the kind to choose and why and so on.
You mentioned playing from Schumann's Fantasie Op. 17.
I don't have it down yet.
Well OK, but you said that somehow you felt that the people at these stores reacted positively to it.
Yes, but they are used to hearing many fine pianists down there. I think they appreciate it, but that's why we try and play these pieces in part; they represent the greatest pianism on some levels.
You posted several pages here about various pianists, you want to discuss them?
They each represent a kind of direction in pianism that is going on these days. George Li was added to the list. This young man, off to Harvard / NE Conservatory, certainly deserves his own page, and he too fits into a certain pattern for pianism.
The pianists you chose were ... 
Before getting to them, let's get back to my trips to New York and those pianos down there.
OK. 
Both stores had lots of good high end product, but again what kind of piano are you or should you be in the market for? 
You think it matters?
I do. I think it matters because it's a way of staying honest with oneself. It would be different for instance if a pianist relied on other people's pianos all the time as many in fact do. I knew someone once who had studied all of the Beethoven sonatas and played them on a Wurlitzer spinet!
How could he do some of that ... ?
 Yeah, I know, some of it he just couldn't do on that piano, but I had him play the same thing, the end of #30, at an electronic keyboard and he knew what to do.
Shaking his head 
Well, piano availability or not is a fact of life for many pianists. Many can only afford some crappy old piano or a cheap electronic keyboard.
You don't like them.
No, they don't represent real pianos to me, but then again my friend's Wurlitzer spinet really doesn't either.
OK, so the pianos.
At Faust Harrison, you'll find the Mason & Hamlin B. This is a 5'4” piano, the strongest brand new baby grand on the planet right now with a fabulous new action. This is a perfect gem of a practise piano, the scale is excellent all the way down, remarkable for a piano this size. 
So compared to a car would this be ?
.... like an American tribute to a Porsche sports car, maybe something with all wheel drive and possibly a hybrid, gull wing doors, etc. I mean, Mason & Hamlin pianos have an almost symphonic quality to their sound, perfect tone all the way up and down the piano and touch that is an extension of your slightest whim, this piano would be every bit as good on a stage in a top tier jazz club, as it would be in your studio or living room. 
... and of course they have much more.
Oh yeah, they have much more. Faust Harrison's inventory at any time is among the deepest in the business.  
And Beethoven's?
I spent a lot of time looking at uprights there.
Didn't you go there looking for Hailun pianos?
Yes, but they didn't have any of the new ones yet. I spent most of my time there looking at uprights.
Why uprights?
Not everyone can use a grand. Some of us live in tight spaces and there are plenty of decent uprights around now that I'd have no trouble recommending to anyone. 
OK, did Faust Harrison have any uprights?
They have some of the best. The two I recall playing both had gorgeous tone and touch characteristics. One was a Bechstein, the same model Debussy used to write all his music. Believe me, you can get this piano to do anything. Schulze Pullmann, an Italian company started there by some Germans after the war, make some beautiful pianos, and then so does C. Bechstein. But at Beethoven's one would find Yamahas, either lightly used or reconditioned, in any case from what I observed, all were in excellent shape. They also had a few other contenders from China including Hailun, which sounded and played fine, except that ergonomically, the piano somehow didn't fit me. 
Laughs 
Well, it's really important to feel comfortable sitting at a piano. You have to have a situation where you can read the music easily, which is different for each of us, and that you are sitting at the right height relative to the keys. It's very important to know how to find one's optimum seating position, which promotes the best posture long term and that's going to be different for each of us. It's why I recommend adjustable benches if you can have them.  
So you consider these upright pianos to be ?
They are all practise pianos by definition. You'd usually only think of a live performance on a grand piano, although some of the uprights can sound well enough in a small space, they really can't fill an auditorium the way a concert grand can, especially in the bass registers. Of course you can do a lot with electronics and amplification but ...
That's cheating! Laughs
So these uprights are still important to consider by far more people than they often are. Their actions are getting better relative to grands too. Fandrich & Sons vertical action is the equal of any grand action and his uprights are gems.
You got to see some of those out in Washington last year too, didn't you?
Yes, and got to hear my nephews play them too, which was even better. We even had one of them play the same piece on an upright with the Fandrich action and one without it and you could absolutely hear the difference.
But, you think there are other uprights ...
I still think that Fandrich & Sons has the best upright action in the best upright pianos on the market, hands down. If one is really picky in regard to piano tone and action, and one wants or needs an upright due to space considerations, Fandrich & Sons would be my first choice. 
All others seek Yamaha?
Or a half dozen other brands, Schulze Pollmann definitely being among them.
But that by no means relegates them to ...
Well, here we come to another question, one regarding motivation. Just what is the purpose of pursuing pianism? For some it is like a duck to water, once encountered it was an instant fit, some are extraordinarily talented; they have no difficulty with reading the music, they face no difficulty with dexterity or other physical limitations that would make playing a piano difficult or impossible. The vast majority of players are occasional players who take up the piano for their own amusement. Most of these have professional careers or are otherwise interested in other things.
You told me once of that fellow at the NE Conservatory ...
That was another lifetime ago.
Yes, but it still fits. He said that many professional musicians were actually trained in other fields and even played at a professional level as amateurs.
There is only one arena where there is a basic difference between a “professional” and an “amateur” and that is that the former has an agent. This was made absolutely clear in Norman Lebrecht's work.
So most people who are active in classical music, even if they are getting paid, are amateurs?
Compared to the remunerations for “stars” they are. This is a serious problem for music and musicians that can only be made better by frank discussions; are these “stars” really worth the money?
I really want to steer the discussion back to pianos for a moment. So you advise people who want a piano to look at good uprights first?
Definitely. Then if they decide they want a grand and can afford it, and most of us eventually do, then one is faced with the obvious; what grand piano makes the most sense for me to own long term?
Some get into it for the “investment” angle.
Not a wise move. People involved in the investment business are used to seeing return on value written everywhere and attempt to apply it to all their purchases. Should something one buys that has some utilitarian value, like a candlestick for instance, increase in value at least 3% per year, as some of them believe? This is tying everything back to money.
Yes, but people buy Steinway because it has the name.
And that name is probably worth $100 million all by itself. It doesn't mean that there aren't other considerations when buying a piano. There are many fine piano makers that have product every bit as good as Steinway's.
What do you think about the recent news concerning Steinway?
It's essentially “taking it private” which is a good thing. It has a better chance of survival that way.
You know they're giving up their 57th Street location?
... and Beethoven's is moving too. So New York is constantly trying to reinvent itself. We can thank Isaac Stern and others for saving Carnegie Hall, which is in the neighbourhood.
Anyway, getting back to pianos.
Never consider it an “investment.” These are essentially machines that eventually need repair and restoration, although that can be after 30 to 60 years of use. Some pianos, as is well known to dealers and technicians the world over, are terribly abused. Many were built during the heyday of piano making before the advent of radio and these were in many cases built of shoddy materials. These are almost never worth considering.
Like your friend's Wurlitzer spinet.
If it doesn't impress you just the slightest bit to play something simple on it, then you wont want to sit down for the long hours it takes to really get good at it.
You told me about wandering through Beethoven's attic of second tier grand pianos on your last visit.
It will be interesting to see what Beethoven's becomes in their new location, whether they have a comparable area. I'll certainly find out. Beethoven's attic, their upstairs, there is where often one found some sleepers. These are pianos that are not always in suitable prep, they aren't supposed to be, as it wouldn't be worth their while, they aren't what most who enter the Manhattan showrooms, are looking for. I suspect most were obtained in trade in. But among these are where a lot more people need to be looking.
You mentioned a nice Baldwin grand.
Yes, from the 1930's I believe, maybe a B, so it was made in their Cincinnati factory. I could tell that it was an extraordinary Baldwin. And you could have had it for little. A potential buyer sees something like this and what they should have in mind is what a technician can do with it to bring it up to where it can shine. Plan to spend several hundred dollars on piano technical work while you save tens of thousands of dollars on the piano.  
So if it was that nice, why wouldn't you have it?
I owned a Baldwin L for many years, and as they say, been there, done that. But that does not mean that I hold Baldwin in low regard. Anything they made from the mid 1950's on back, is better than average and occasionally well above average.
Has your opinion changed regarding baby grands?
Yes and no. If you're going for the shape of a grand rather than the sound or the action, then there are certainly some tremendous grand pianos out there in the 5'3” to 5'6” range to choose from that would certainly make excellent practise pianos. But many are overlooking the space and money values an upright piano represents. Fandrich gets my top spot nod, but the Europeans and Asians certainly offer some extraordinary upright pianos. The New York stores have plenty to choose from.
Now onto practise sessions.
OK. You should visit your piano for a session at least once a day. You can make it for as long as a half hour or even less, to as long as two hours. I'm sorry, but anything more begins to start some processes in the mind and body that we do not want, a certain kind of automaton performance without cognition. Practise sessions should follow certain natural patterns. It all begins with how one sits at the piano, getting the ergonomics of keyboard, pedals and seat height just right. Then there are the types of sessions. Long sessions are where one gives oneself a concert and evaluates the performance. One may or may not decide to stop and return and rework a passage, but this usually is not the time to be doing that. Shorter practise sessions are of the sort where one is working on a particular passage. The repeats required tend to drive other people mad so it's best to choose times for these sessions when no one else is around.
You spoke earlier to me about hearing passages of music in your head while you are doing something else.
Yes, this inevitably happens to most musicians as they become involved in their music, they begin hearing it and want to respond by recreating it on their own instruments. Passages that are difficult require a process of breaking them down into their simplest parts and then often laboriously putting them back together, not at full speed at first, but later bringing the constructed parts up to speed.
So there are short practise sessions that are more like ...
... physical drills than like playing music. You sit down at the music making machine and you are drilling your fingers into performing certain kinds of passage work. Very often the only thought required is getting your mind to feel the changes in muscles in the fingers, wrists, arms, neck and back, to relax as much as possible and to let breathing be as natural as possible. There are times and places for more forceful attacks, but even so, most pianists perform these motions with too much extra muscular involvement. The natural force of gravity should be enough.
So you are saying that your practise sessions look much like these.
They are largely either “recitals to oneself” or they are specific to a particular problem posed by a particular composition. But there is a third kind and that is “exploratory reading.” Some who easily acquire the ability to read music want to spend their time plying through, or attempting to do so, as much music as they possibly can. I've known a few of these. But few of those that do this, excluding the other kinds of practise sessions, have actually buckled down to attempting to play from memory any single piece or group of pieces. That said, these are invaluable sessions for every pianist and should not be confused with sessions where one is working on a specific set of pieces for performance.
OK, then you and I were talking about performance pianos.
Well, these are the pianos that are intended for music before the public. They are meant to convey piano sound to large spaces. A piano can only really be heard well in a confined space. Out of doors, their sound seems to die away even more quickly than usual.
You have seen many of these too.
Oh yes, from the Bosendorfer Imperial Grand and the various others by Sauter (at Beethoven's), Steingraeber & Sohn (at Allegro), Fazioli (at Klavierhaus) and many fine Steinways (all of them). These are the pianos for those who have something to play. But isn't it more important for most people to find a piano on which they can learn something to play before encountering these performance pianos? If you want to take up the piano, it seems to me far better to start with a good reliable upright than blowing a huge amount of money (most of the performance pianos cost as much as a nice car or small house) on a piano whose best characteristics can only be heard in a large performance space. Yes, the big pianos are impressive. They should be. But most people don't live in houses with rooms specifically designed as concert halls. And anyway, it's about the music.
So about gaining a repertoire.
Some piano technicians I've known could actually play Chopin's fantasie-impromptu Op. 66 at full speed and perhaps nothing else. I still can't make my hands do it. Building a repertoire is about assembling something piece by piece until one has a programme, or several programmes, each an hour and a half or so long, that one can perform at will when they encounter a performance piano. You start simple and strong and build grace and agility with each succeeding piece. Some pianists stick to one composer, or just a few, like the photographer, Ansel Adams, who supposedly played nothing but Bach and Ravel. Others may play one piece by someone and that will be it. Each piece in their repertoire is by someone else. Most conservatory performance programs stress a balance between musical periods. This follows a practise going back to the early 19th century, when Felix Mendelssohn included Bach in the regular performance repertoire. Other neglected early composers would be added. Meanwhile, the 20th century now lying behind us, the various masterpieces of that era are emerging too. It's easy to say that there were far too many styles alive and thriving during the past century that a concert (or several) featuring nothing but 20th century music is certainly possible.
You'd expect to hear more of what?
You'd have to begin with those born in the 19th century; Ferruccio Busoni. Amy Beach, Wilhelm Stenhammar, Alexander Scriabin, who has certainly earned a place in the piano repertoire, Charles Ives is gaining popularity, Maurice Ravel has of course attained eternal status.
Yes, but we know of these, who of those most don't know?
There's Arnold Bax and York Bowen, there's Alberto Ginastera, I used to know someone who made his music her speciality. Nikolai Medtner is interesting as is Selim Palmgren. Francis Poulenc wrote some interesting things. There's really so much music that's worth programming, all from the 20th century alone, that it's amazing.
So, it just matters if you decide to take on a piece and work away at it until you have it? 
Essentially, yes. But there's still a lot of breaking it down, bit by bit, phrase by phrase, note by note sometimes. It's VERY helpful to play just the right hand or just the left hand, making sure that you have all the notes correct. Of course some pieces are written in such a way that you can't really do that, but where possible, you should use any technique to somehow get the notes into your mind and then down into your fingers. Again, learn to hear it first, sing it almost, before you can play it.
So again, it's pianos, practise and pieces.
That's the logical beginning and ongoing method whether one uses a teacher or not.
You want to say something about piano teachers?
For most people they could be helpful, but I would look for someone to coach you, to correct your mistakes (hopefully without marking up your music, which infuriates me), someone who will drive you forward a little, just enough until you are convinced that it really is worth it to keep practising and playing. You'll want someone who is rational and precise, who uses methods that are natural and easy rather than rigorous and extreme.
That may be a problem.
Yes, well finding rational people in any discipline is becoming rare because of the universal training everyone has been subjected to.
Very little willingness to pursue any discipline too.
Pianism has to reach beyond mere discipline if it is to succeed. It has to be approached as something that can literally change your life.
What's in store for your blogs?
The E. C. Riegel blog was down for 2 months and has come back up to receiving almost as many hits since as it received before it was taken down. We came back the first week of May and are getting hits from all over the world, particularly from Russia.
Interesting.
Yeah, so that one will continue. The Linton Bequest, the sci-fi adventure mystery novel I wrote a few years ago, is all up there and has had less than a third of the hits of the Riegel blog. Turns out I was wrong. More people would rather read about something that's potentially real than anything they know is intended as fiction.
It may be the times we're in.
No doubt.
This blog?
More of the same, oh yes, the list of pianists I put up.
Yes?
Well George Li is a fabulous young talent and all the world of music agents loves that.
But you think he has talent.
Oh yes, he and his brother Andrew too.
The others?
Glenn Hardy is someone I knew during college years and a little after that.  I've always admired him as a musician. He was very seriously involved in building harpsichords at one time, he built many fine ones, and also studied early music, but Glenn was always attracted to the world of early jazz and related music. He actually sets about playing it as if he's playing something classical and his approach has produced many really astounding performances. He's made many CD's and I encourage all those interested in these genres to purchase them from Glenn.
And the others?
Justine Verdier is a young French pianist who has benefited from some exemplary European musicians and musical academies. She and her betrothed formed a duo and play four hand piano music in concerts around Europe. I know a few other piano duos. Whether it's two pianos or one piano four hands, the music for this genre is important and should be gaining in interest everywhere.
Violetta Egorova is a Russian pianist with both great strength for playing really demanding compositions; her Liszt is amazing, as well as the ability to coax the most haunting intentions from very soft piano music, particularly her Mozart, which she somehow makes sound as though she's playing Chopin. She spends he summers teaching music in southern Italy. What I always wish for with Violetta is that she somehow finds someone that will champion her and give particular attention to producing the best recordings possible of all her future performances. That should apply to all pianists as how they sound is part of their message.
Viktoriya Yermolyeva is someone with a rigorous classical piano education who decided to turn their attention to contemporary popular music. Anyone can tell right away that regardless of the musical content, she puts herself right into it and remarkably manages to produce an accurate distillation of each piece. We encourage all who can to support her efforts.
So you aren't one of those that insists that nothing but classical is real music?
There are those in other fields known to me that regard one form of something so superior to all others that they deny the existence of all else.
“Gold bugs” and money?
Laughs
Like it or not, the easiest form of irrationality is to insist that something that exists, does not in fact exist; nothing but gold and silver is money, nothing but classical music is music. These are very similar ideas that are both contradicted by apparent reality. Meanwhile, notice how often, here and there, one hears a piano used in advertising or movies, etc. Like it or not all these venues give new life to the piano.
Thanks for this interview, hope your readers enjoy it. Anything more?
Yes, there is. As a fitting end for this interview, I offer my audience the following video performance of Franz Schubert's Fantasy in f minor D 940 played by Paul Badura-Skoda et Jörg Demus, two of my favourites from my childhood. Look then at these two old men in their 80's sitting there side by side, playing a piece they probably have known since they were young men, a piece composed by a young man who would never see his 32nd birthday, who probably wrote it knowing he was going to die soon.
Really?
Yeah, really. There is something sort of spellbinding about this. They are playing a Bösendorfer. It doesn't include the whole piece, they cut off the last of it, where Schubert has decided to close his lament with a fast scherzo in a minor key, with something faintly diabolical about it.
A means of making peace with death?
Perhaps.
Well again, thanks for the interview, let's make the next one sooner than later.
Will try. 

FINIS

Sunday, July 7, 2013

Another “found” Schubert Symphony

 
“Raymond Leppard decided to re-orchestrate this great work more in the style of Schubert himself, using the similar style and instrumentation Schubert incorporated in the "Unfinished Symphony" of 1822, written two years previous to this Grand Duo.

This performance by the Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Raymond Leppard in November 1990.”

Schubert - Symphony in C Major (1824) (Grand Duo D. 812)
III. Scherzo: Allegro vivace
IV.Finale: Allegro vivace


[Update 14 July, 2013] The original composition was written for piano four hands as a Sonata. This music has to be some of my all time favourite. I even featured it in my book. A great performance of it exists featuring Jonathan Plowright and Aaron Shorr in concert at the Royal Conservatoire of Scotland on the 27 January 2012.


Sunday, June 2, 2013

The Brahms Chorale Preludes – For whenever you need them

These eleven pieces are the last that Johannes Brahms wrote. They are each very brief, literally just settings of hymns as was done by Brahms' inspiration throughout his life, J. S. Bach. They were published after Brahms' death as his Op. 122. They were all composed in 1896, the year before he died.

1. Mein Jesu, der du mich zumLustspiel ewiglich

This is to be translated as, “My Jesu, Thou who me to delight forever” is an extinct hymn from one of Brahms' old Lutheran hymnals. Brahms was a collector of old music and some old books and monographs. We would not have the Scarlatti sonatas if it hadn't been for Brahms buying them and bestowing them to posterity after his death. But more to the point, the phrase in German implies something closer to, “My Jesus, Thou who made a fool of me forever.” The piece is far from cheery. Indeed it is deep and rapt ... and of course it could just as easily have been written by Johann Sebastian Bach. The ever self-effacing Brahms, who somehow saw the futility of it all, seemingly at the end of his life faced the inevitable perplexities with a mixture of resignation and quiet anticipation. 

Bernard Lagacé, 1978, performed on the Wolff Organ at the Eighth Church of Christ, Scientist, New York City, Titanic, serial number TI-38. The organ was built in 1977 by Hellmuth Wolff of Montreal.

2. Herzliebster Jesu, was hast duverbrochen 

This one translated as “Dearest Jesus, what crime have you done?” often as not to indicate the innocence of Jesus, but just as likely, there was a personal twist to it, for perhaps Brahms was wrestling with his own unbelief; what crime had Jesus done to he, Brahms, to force his acceptance?

Marco Limone performed on the Bossi organ at Santuario della Madonna degli Angeli in Turin, Italy in 2010.

Very simply, as it chugs forth, “Oh World, I leave you.” There are very simple heart rending strains here which are easily lost if this piece is played too slowly.

Cor de Jong performed on the Maarschalkerweerd organ at Leiden in Holland, perhaps just before the end of February, this year.

4. Herzlich tut mich erfreuen

“Heartfelt acts please me,” admonishes one to do virtuous actions from the heart as they please the Almighty.

Anne-Gaëlle Chanon performed on the Cavaillé-Coll organ at the Cathedral of St. Omer in Saint-Omer, France as part of a recital on 29 September, 2012 (had you been one of the lucky ones to have been there).

An alternate version, an arrangement by Ferruccio Busoni (1866-1924), here

Paul Jacobs (1930-1983) of Bach Busoni fame, plays this. [Jacobs was an American pianist best known for his performances of twentieth-century music, who also gained recognition for his work with early keyboards, performing frequently with Baroque ensembles. Jacobs was the New York Philharmonic's official pianist (from 1961) and harpsichordist (from 1974) until his death. He held the post during the tenure of three music directors.]

“Dress up oh dear soul,” is perhaps a song to call Christian believers into recalling the coming wedding feast that is to be attended by all the invited ... sometime long after we are all dead.

Giuseppe Raccuglia performed on the Klais organ of St. Peter's Church, Badenweiler (Germany), sometime before April, 2011.

An alternate version, an arrangement by Ferruccio Busoni (1866-1924), here 

Paul Jacobs (1930-1983) of Bach Busoni fame, plays this.

6. O wie selig seid ihr doch, ihr Frommen

As possible reference to the Virgin Mary; if you would be blessed, be faithful as she was blessed.

Gerard van Reenen performed on a harmonium built by Alexandre, Paris 1880, sometime before June, 2012.
 
7. O Gott, du frommer Gott

Literally, “God, you faithful God” is nevertheless in a minor key and meditates on perhaps all those ways in which we could not possibly fathom God's beneficence.

Kay Johannsen performed on the Mühleisen organ at the Stiftskirche in Stuttgart (Germany) in 2011.

8. Es ist ein Ros' entsprungen 

Perhaps the most famous piece of the lot, it would be another setting of “Lo how a rose e'er blooming,” but you can't tell because it isn't the same song from the English late middle ages we may have known from our own childhoods long ago. What is clear about this one, maybe more than any of the others in this set, is that it really betrays its author as Brahms with just about every phrase.

Lorenzo Antinori performed on the Morettini organ in the Basilica Concattedrale di Cagli in Italy at a concert there in 2012.

Alternate version, arranged by Harold Bauer (1873-1951) here 

Performed by John Peace 2011, Wendover Studios. He thereafter plays #11, #10 and #4.
 
9. Herzlich tut mich verlangen

This is another refrain, “heartfelt actions are required of me.” We are free to imagine why this was left here for us to ponder. What could have been on Brahms mind as he contemplated his own death is beyond our comprehension.

Duo Tal & Groethuysen, piano recorded on 30th of January 2011 at the Church of Rougemont during the Sommets Musicaux de Gstaad (Switzerland) 2011. Piano arrangements like this is how more of these chorale preludes can reach more people.

10. Herzlich tut mich verlangen (second version)

More “Heartfelt acts please me,” so is Brahms pleading for his eternal life? Of course, we'll never know.

Jolanda Zwoferink performed on the Marcussen organ Sint-Laurenskerk, Rotterdam, Holland sometime before 16 February, 2010.

An alternate version, transcribed by Feruccio Busoni here

Performed by Akamatsu, Rintaro.

 
11. O Welt, ich muss dich lassen

Concluding with more “Oh World, I leave you.” Perhaps at last, both Brahms and we ourselves may find peace and rest for our souls.

Bernard Lagacé, 1978, performed on the Wolff Organ at the Eighth Church of Christ, Scientist, New York City, Titanic, serial number TI-38. The organ was built in 1977 by Hellmuth Wolff of Montreal.

Bonus! Prelude and Fugue in g MinorOp. Post #10

Christian Barthen performed on the organ in the Basilica of St. John in Saarbrücken, Germany.

Thank-you for examining with me the last works of Johannes Brahms.

FINIS


Tuesday, May 14, 2013

The Symphonies of Anton Bruckner


Another post concerning Bruckner is here.

On Saturday, 23 February, a friend and I attended a concert at Bard College featuring Bruckner's 8th symphony in its original 1887 version, one I'd never heard before. The music was played by the American Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Leon Botstein in a stunning performance that I'm pretty sure was not fully appreciated by most of the audience. After all, how many even of the most seasoned concert audiences know much if anything about Bruckner?

Anton Bruckner (1824-1896), the Austrian composer, is noted primarily for his symphonies and his church music. Johannes Brahms, who did not seemingly like Bruckner personally, or at least not his work, referred to Bruckner's “great snakes of symphonies” for they are all long and snake about both thematically and harmonically, all within a certain greatly elongated sonata allegro form. Bruckner wrote eleven symphonies between 1863 and the time of his death in 1896. His works begin with the Study Symphony in F minor. He then wrote the uniquely named symphony No. 0 in d minor in 1869, henceforth the Zero. Thereafter he wrote nine more. his last titled Symphony No. 9 (although it's really his eleventh) left unfinished at his death, it's final movement incomplete. Knowing he might not live long enough to complete this last symphony, Bruckner suggested that his Te Deum be played as the final movement.

For much of this music, you will perhaps want to get into a nice comfortable chair and put on a good set of headphones that can really take the dynamic ranges, kick your feet up and relax. This is the kind of music to accompany some great motion picture one might create in one's mind. Of course another aspect we shall be encountering is the music that again was being written by residents of Vienna, leading up to the so called Second Vienna School (Zweite Wiener Schule, Neue Wiener Schule), this music was to bridge the gap between the Romantic era and the atonalism of the 20th century. The chief musical vehicle was the symphony, as it had been for what some may call the First Vienna School that had formed around Joseph Haydn, who wrote more symphonies than anyone else.

Study Symphony in f minor (1863)
[1] Allegro molto vivace
(There are a few cuts in this performance, but this is the only version of this movement on You Tube that comes to a conclusion.)
[2] Andante molto 7:03 
[3] Scherzo - Schnell 5:25
[4] Allegro 6:46 

Unattributed but possibly the Royal Scottish National Orchestra (Glasgow) conducted by Georg Tintner. 

At its writing, the composer was 39 years old. We hear various obvious steals throughout, from sources as far back as Mozart and Beethoven, through Mendelssohn and Schumann. But some of what will become the more pronounced Bruckner style are already present. This is most definitely an under rated symphony which should be performed more often as a good opener in a programme paired perhaps with a 20th century masterpiece or two for the second half of a concert. The work lasts about three quarters of an hour and will fully exercise all capabilities of a large symphony orchestra. 
1. Allegro
2. Andante
3. Scherzo: Presto — Trio: Langsamer und ruhiger
4. Finale: Moderato — Allegro vivace

Sir George Solti conducts the Chicago Symphony Orchestra

The Zero lasts almost 40 minutes and might actually be Bruckner's third in order of composition. The next one, the official 1st symphony, was written three years earlier and this one could have been at least begun the same year. In any case Bruckner is 45 at its completion. From the standpoint of the previous Study Symphony, it would seem that Bruckner fashioned two symphonies, one he rejected, the Zero, whilst the other became the official beginning of his legacy. Amazing that many, perhaps most just neglect these works as useless. The only problem with discarding them is that these first two symphonies each contain a lot of musical material, some of extraordinary value considering who might have been looking, or listening. But no one really was. Is it then a coincidence that certain weird little orchestral textures found in these works turn up in works by later composers? We'll probably never know. Suffice it to say that certain ideas seem to have currency and draw their own admirers during their own particular times. This symphony is also quite full of steals. But one must after all learn from someone. The cult of overt individualism is certainly overrated. As it is, much in these early symphonies already peculiar to Bruckner's style, will definitely influence Mahler and of course the unfortunate Hans Rott, as well as others. It has been often said that musically, Bruckner owes the most to Wagner, but how differently did each employ similar orchestral ideas? Both composers wrote music that is large and expresses many aspects of raw natural power, as well as suggesting natural elements, creatures in a forest, but perhaps only accidentally. Else we are liable to accept that Bruckner, who had studied counterpoint extensively for many years, was using his symphonies to plumb the mysteries of orchestral music as an exercise in sheer intellectual study; one of the elements in the Quadrivium is Music. Everything we know of the studied and studious nature of Bruckner suggests that this might even have been exactly his intentions. 

Symphony No.1 in C minor (1868) "das kecke Beserl"  
1. Allegro (C minor)
2. Adagio (A-flat major)
3. Scherzo: Lebhaft (G minor) – Trio: Langsam (G major)
4. Finale: Bewegt und feurig (C minor)

Sir Geg Solti conducts the Chicago Symphony Orchestra.

Though complete after a fashion in 1868, he revised it until 1891, dedicated it to the University of Vienna, in the main completed before he completed the Zero, this work provides ample evidence that very much of what Bruckner would accomplish was already fully alive in this work. The amazing and revealing steals also continue, from various sources, a few known, like Beethoven and Wagner, while other steals are more obscure. But from the opening bars of the first movement, we are aware of the similarity with the opening of Mahler's 6th, so in music as everywhere else, stealing occurs frequently. But of course we are of a mind not to be terribly concerned with various ways composers plagiarize ideas from each other because we recognize that they were in their way in this way, not so much stealing as paying the purloined from composer a sincere compliment. Bruckner's symphonies are replete with references to certain elements in Wagner's style while not deliberately quoting passages from specific works. It is well known that Bruckner paid deliberate tribute to Wagner, and that's putting it mildly.

Symphony No. 2 in c minor (1872)  
1. Moderato, (C minor)  
2. Feierlich, etwas bewegt, (A-flat major)
3. Scherzo: Mäßig schnell, (C minor) - Trio: Gleiches Tempo, (C major)
4. Finale: Ziemlich schnell, (C minor)

Riccardo Muti conducts the Wiener Philharmoniker at a live concert in the Musikverein, Vienna, 13 April, 2008. (1877 version where the 2nd and 3rd movements are reversed from the original versions)

Revised and reworked until it was published in 1892, this is a fleet work in some respects compared with its predecessor, with again plenty in it that will be picked over by Mahler for ideas that in his hands would sound quite different. Bruckner, as is customarily conceived, was concerned with evoking nature as a tribute to nature's creator, since Bruckner was never far from his apparently quite fervent religious devotion. What may be Bruckner's case, as well or even instead, is that he was primarily a composer operating in the ways mathematicians are devoted to mathematics in that his works are themselves immense “studies” intended to do exactly what they accomplished in the case of Mahler and others, who would apparently learn much from Bruckner's efforts.

Symphony No.3 in d minor, “Wagner” (original 1873 version)
1. Gemäßigt, mehr bewegt, misterioso (also Sehr langsam, misterioso)—d minor
2. Adagio. Bewegt, quasi Andante—E-flat major
3. Scherzo. Ziemlich schnell (also Sehr schnell)—d minor
4. Finale. Allegro (also Ziemlich schnell)—d minor

Yannick Nézet-Séguin conducting the Staatskapelle Dresden at a concert in the Semperoper, Dresden, Germany on 22 September, 2008.

The first movement is dominated by an enigmatic figure that dramatically pops up amid otherwise passages suggesting natural surroundings. Much else goes on as well. This work was dedicated to Richard Wagner. In the dedication, Bruckner wrote of Wagner as "the unreachable world-famous noble master of poetry and music." Flattery got one best wishes from the cantankerous old composer. Money of course got them Wagner's blessings and later perhaps a personal stab in the back. The imperturbably innocent Bruckner hadn't either vanity or money, so probably Wagner's best wishes were a gentle “what possible harm could he do?” kind of brush off. In any case Bruckner might have been warned that Wagner was usually a dangerous friend.

The music itself is almost the perfect bridge between Beethoven (and even Haydn) and Mahler, through the lens of Wagner. The second movement is where classical Vienna meets the unanswerable questions from Tristan und Isolde. Of course that work dates from before 1860 and now 13 years later, the nearly 50 year old Bruckner writes this music. The difference between Wagner and Bruckner is in the ground of their mysticism. Bruckner's is sacred, whilst Wagner's is profane. Wagner believed in nobody but himself, while Bruckner believed he was merely another of God's creatures, a comparative nobody. The difference in their music and how it relates to the Messianic and redemptive strains in Mahler are all found here. Played competently, and yes, with all the real references directly back to Haydn, this movement become the musical apotheosis of the Viennese (and late German Romantic) culture of that period, when matters of honour and heroism were familiar to all.

This Scherzo is going to be a kind of model for other dance music in the symphonies that would follow. Bruckner is pairing brutal and brusque musical figures with candid fleet footedness and again the sense that one could take the tone centre of the music anywhere at all at any moment. If you like Mahler, hear this trio and you will have no doubt of the inspiration. But this is Bruckner, so there is ease and unmarred happiness instead of strain and pain.

The finale is in d minor, titanic and flexed. Played as it is here, it really shows off the full capabilities of a great orchestra. Where did Bruckner get some of this? Oh, from Schubert, from other prosaic composers of schmaltzy dance music of the period, out of his counterpoint books. The part writing and how it all stands out as distinct and weaves itself together flawlessly are demonstrated as casually as having a walk (or ride) through the country. There is even a place where the music seems to pause and take a little rest, then resumes. Bruckner doesn't let you linger too long ; he just keeps the walk (ride) going where it naturally would if it were ... out of that particular place in space and time that was the late 19th century in Vienna, thirty years and another lifetime ahead of the Great War. The huge clouds of noise he gets up in this symphony never sound as if they are quite the premonition of a great war, but rather of some dramatic weather or natural event or some possible beneficent act of the Almighty. Nevertheless, to Anton Bruckner, these may have in fact been nothing more than great music lessons writ large. Did he mock himself even near the end of this last movement? It's certainly possible.

Symphony No.4 in E flat major, "Die Romantische" (1874-1888)
1. Bewegt, nicht zu schnell (E-flat major) 
2. Andante, quasi allegretto (C minor)
3. Scherzo. Bewegt - Trio: Nicht zu schnell (B-flat major)
4. Finale: Bewegt, doch nicht zu schnell (E-flat major)

Daniel Barenboim conducting Wiener Philharmonier,
Royal Albert Hall, London, 3 9 / 2007


The Romantic symphony is one of Bruckner's best known, premiered in 1881 by Hans Richter in Vienna with great success. Bruckner used the name Romantic for this work to depict heroic tales rather than love stories. Wagner gave this work his personal approval, which I'm sure helped secure the work both publicity and performances.

Symphony No 5 in B flat Major (1875-1876) 
1. Introduction (Adagio) — Allegro. B-flat major.
2. Adagio. Sehr langsam. D minor.
3. Scherzo. Molto vivace D minor.
4. Finale (Adagio) — Allegro moderato. B-flat major.

Nikolaus Harnoncourt conducting Wiener Philharmoniker
Festspielhaus, Salzburg, 28 8 / 2005

First performed in completed form in 1887 (published in 1897), a performance capable of lasting an hour and a half! this work is yet of a more straightforward and simpler design than those which follow it, and many of the devices used are hence perhaps more memorable. There is a lot of string plucking; pizzicato, throughout this work. Bruckner uses the slow walking theme of the academic sounding introduction to the first movement for material to add to the development section. The effect might seem heroic and pastoral by turns. Here again, as we have and will see, vast orchestral walls succeed one another with really masterful applications of Wagnerian orchestration as if the orchestra is played as a vast organ, that being Bruckner's principle instrument.

The second movement features possibly more bucolic passages, but these would likely be vistas framed by huge glaciated fastnesses, not your usual placid hills and valleys back home. He tries birhymicality over a few measures and repeats it later in the form's rebound so you know he's serious. Here and there an odd phrase will remind you of Elgar.

Bruckner essays many more daring things in the Scherzo, which especially in the Trio sounds like Mahler, who always claimed Bruckner as inspiration. Nobody writes in a vacuum.

The Finale begins as did the first movement, the same stately academic walk, but then successive themes from the first movement are tried until a new theme is taken up in a fugue. This one certainly gets inspiration from Beethoven's Große Fuge. But then Bruckner breaks free of it into more of his usual symphonic strands, more string plucking giving that “urban” quality to many of the passages. But then there are the brass choirs signifying something more like attending high mass, which in Catholic Austria was almost a token of patriotism to the Hapsburg regime and the realm it signified. As with much in Bruckner, it's not over til it's over and you will feel a few false ends before it all comes to the usual colossal finish. What do you expect from someone that uses a fugue as the substitute for the first subject in a sonata allegro form?

Symphony No 6 in A Major (1879-1881)
1. Majestoso 
2. Adagio. Sehr feierlich
3. Scherzo. Nicht schnell — Trio. Langsam
4. Finale. Bewegt, doch nicht zu schnell

Christoph Eschenbach conducts the Wiener Philharmoniker in the Musikverein, Vienna, in a live performance, 10 December, 2008. 

He's in his mid fifties as he writes this, perhaps the least well known of Bruckner's symphonies, and for that reason it will probably over time become better known. It lasts the regulation hour in length, and contains many exquisite touches and stunning orchestral effects. The first movement, Majestoso, presents us with thematic material and contexts which cannot set for us any definite key, the second movement is actually in sonata form, the third movement predates the scherzo in his 8th symphony, the finale almost a symphony in itself. 

Symphony No 7 in E Major (1881-1882)
1. Allegro moderato (E major) 
2. Adagio. Sehr feierlich und sehr langsam (C-sharp minor)
3. Scherzo. Sehr schnell (A minor)
4. Finale. Bewegt, doch nicht schnell (E major)

Bernard Haitink conducts the Staatskapelle Dresden in the Royal Albert Hall, London in a live performance, 9 March, 2004. This is one for headphones as some of the playing is really gorgeous.

This symphony, which runs a little more than an hour, won Bruckner his greatest public success during his lifetime, and why not? It's one of the tighter of his conceptions for one thing, and his orchestration is at its best. Bruckner is as some suppose imitating nature. But it could as well be that he is writing pure music as much of it has geometric progression, structure and substance, of course drawn from Wagner, but put to far different uses. Much of it also sounds like early Mahler, who would be deeply influenced by this music. Other trademarks of Bruckner's style are his occasional references to phrase painting from the First Vienna School, because after all he is in Vienna and has inherited their craft. This piece was being written in that fateful year, 1881, that would see the première of Brahms' second piano concerto and the birth of Béla Bartók. It was first performed in 1884 and revised in 1885.

Symphony No. 8 in c minor (original version, 1887) 
1. Allegro moderato
2. Scherzo. Allegro moderato; Trio. Langsam
3. Adagio. Feierlich langsam, doch nicht schleppend
4. Finale. Feierlich, nicht schnell

Vladimir Fedoseyev conducts the Moscow Radio Symphony Orchestra.

Most have heard this in later versions that Bruckner should never have allowed to be edited. This is the way he originally heard and wrote it. Much of it comes across as more original and better integrated and some of the music, notably in the Third movement, is totally different.

Symphony No. 9 in d minor (incomplete in 1896)
1. Feierlich, misterioso
2. Scherzo. Bewegt, lebhaft - Trio. Schnell
3. Adagio. Langsam, feierlich

Bernard Haitink conducts the Chicago Symphony Orchestra in a live concert at Orchestra Hall, Chicago, 14 November, 2009. 

The culmination of all Bruckner's symphonic output was this enigmatic music that somehow crystallized his unique style. Most will never hear more than these three movements and for most they will always be more than enough. But This symphony had sketches for the usual fourth movement and a story goes that Bruckner, realizing that he would not complete this work before his death, suggested that his Te Deum be played as its finale. The English composer, Robert Simpson, among many disputed this, but we are including the Te Deum here anyway as in fact a very fitting way to complete this last of Bruckner's symphonies. 

Te Deum in C major (1884) 
1. "Te Deum laudamus" - Allegro, Feierlich, mit Kraft, common time, C major
2. "Te ergo quaesumus" - Moderato, common time, F minor
3. "Aeterna fac" - Allegro, Feierlich, mit Kraft, common time, D minor
4. "Salvum fac populum tuum" - Moderato, common time, F minor
5. "In Te, Domine speravi" - Mäßig bewegt, common time, C major

Soprano: Krassimira Stoyanova
Mezzo-soprano: Yvonne Naef
Tenor: Christoph Strehl
Bass: Günther Groissböck

Chor des Bayerischen Rundfunks
Chorus Master: Simon Halsey

Bernard Haitink conducting the Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks in a live concert in the Herkulessaal, München, 12 November, 2010.

This final set of works, the 9th symphony and Te Deum are works both dedicated to God, Bruckner's very Roman Catholic God. This is in a way a redux of Beethoven's 9th and Missa solemnis in D major, Op. 123, itself a monumental and quite dramatic setting of the Catholic mass. Bruckner's music harkens back to those times in an earlier Vienna.

The parts that remained in Bruckner's music from that earlier period also reflected the continuity of culture, society and governance that would be broken apart within twenty years of Bruckner's death. But what we have of Bruckner's music today is a tribute to the vastness and uniqueness of his conceptions within the dynamic framework of personalities as diverse as Wagner and Bach; such are the complexities of his musical steals.

Someone who would learn from Bruckner, or at least his pupils, would be the young American composer, Charles Ives, whose first two symphonies are full of clever steals. During the same period we have many American symphonists, known these days as the New England School (academics are so very fond of attributing some artistic and stylistic genres to the term “school”), whose methods were essentially the same as Bruckner's. But though these composers had a small staunch following among certain classes of Bostonians, their popularity and influence was short lived as the Great War and the Jazz Age would change all of that forever.

Thank-you so very much for spending a little time investigating the fascinating though often neglected musical world of Anton Bruckner.

FINIS

Saturday, May 11, 2013

A Tour of Mozart's String Quartets



Returning to music which has long been a favourite since I was maybe twenty-three, and having just heard a superb live performance of the 20th in D Major (Emerson String Quartet no less) called the “Hoffmeister” after Mozart's friend, Franz Anton Hoffmeister, a music publisher (promoter) in Vienna, where it was written in 1786. Mozart had just turned 30 and had a mere five more years to live. The whole piece is very clever: sometimes you wonder how he could have possibly heard it all so perfectly and how it only takes four people to play it. What I've always liked most about this quartet is the development section in the first movement, where a kind of imitation of spinning carriage wheels makes you think that perhaps he actually did write it while riding in a carriage. After all, he was Mozart and certainly could have done such things. In fact each of the movements in this quartet features some kind of imitation of the experience or expression of physical motion. After all, they call them movements, don't they?

The best way to set out to look into any particular form of a classical composer's music is by getting the perspective of the whole and then breaking it down into appropriate sub-categories. In the case of Mozart's string quartets, we have 23 of them written between 1770 (the year Beethoven was born) and 1790, a year before Mozart died. That's 23 four part pieces, each lasting between fifteen and twenty-five minutes, written for two violins a viola and a violincello (... a cello). I wont be providing an exhaustive list of links on this tour, so that you can seek out performances, recordings or sheet music on your own.

The Lodi Quartet

The first string quartet, rarely heard, written when Wolfgang was fourteen, already displays considerable musical maturity, what Papa Haydn would later recognize as Mozart's good taste. In the totality of Mozart's string quartets, this one stands by itself. While it borrows techniques from the Italians (it's meant to commemorate the town of Lodi, Italy after all) and the Haydns (both Franz Josef and Michael), this quartet is already marked by Mozart's unmistakeable style. Here the first two movements are played by the Aiana String Quartet as they played them at Dartmouth College, Hanover, New Hampshire, December 5th, 2010. These small intimate chances to hear really good chamber music playing are among the most memorable concert experiences for a lot of us. These players really get it too. For the third and fourth movements, I chose the performance by Quartet Casals as they played them in Barcelona on December 28, 2006.

String Quartet #1 in G Major “Lodi” K 80 (1770) 
[Part 1] 1. Adagio  
[Part 2] 2. Allegro 
[Part 3] 3. Menuetto 
4. Rondeau

The Milanese Quartets 

The next quartets are a set of six written in 1772-1773 while in and around Milan, Italy, hence they are called Milanese Quartets. Mozart would occasionally sojourn in Milan, not too far from his native Salzburg, expecting to earn something while plying his trade composing operas. He was in his mid-teens, writing these string quartets as part musical exercise, for himself and any other players who happen upon them. They are all light weight stuff compared with what he would later compose in this form: instead of the usual four movements, these all have only three. They are listed as follows:

1 Quartet # 2 in D major, K. 155
2 Quartet # 3 in G major, K. 156
3 Quartet # 4 in C major, K. 157
4 Quartet # 5 in F major, K. 158
5 Quatet # 6 in B flat major, K. 159
6 Quartet # 7 in E flat major, K. 160

The second quartet of this set, Quartet# 3 in G major K 156 is played by Marco Ferri and Michele Poggio, Francoise Renard, viola and Enrico Ferri, cello. I suppose they played it sometime before its posting on 14 April, 2012, so fairly recently. The movements are marked Presto, Adagio and Tempo di minuetto. It was written in 1772 in Milan and Mozart was then just 14 years old. As you listen, imagine what might have prompted such theatrical devices in the sombre Adagio to have sprung forth from a young teenaged boy, who was in most respects expected to comport himself as a grown man! The true genius of Mozart is always quite astounding.

The Haydn Quartets, written by Mozart

Considered together as one of Mozart's crowning achievements, these six expertly crafted masterpieces, written between 1782 and 1785, the vibrant first five years of his last ten years in Vienna, amply demonstrate the classical dimensions of the form. Any one of these is a pleasure to hear. They have been used in a variety of ways, usually as background music to dinner parties among the discriminating and well to do. They were also often played at late night soirés by virtuosi among the nobility and diplomats. But locked away in each of them are the folk genres of the people from whence many of the musicians of the times in classical Viennese society came; from the lower classes of German, Italian, Hungarian, Slavonic and Jewish extraction. Though I like them all, my favourite is the last one, subtitled "Dissonance." These are listed as follows:

1. String Quartet # 14 in G major, K. 387 (1782)
2. String Quartet # 15 in D minor, K. 421 (1783)
3. String Quartet # 16 in E-flat major, K. 428 (1783)
4. String Quartet # 17 in B flat major ("Hunt"), K. 458 (1784)
5. String Quartet # 18 in A major, K. 464 (1785)
6. String Quartet # 19 in C major ("Dissonance"), K. 465 (1785)

(Now if you want to take a departure from the main tour, for those who like it so far, or who know the territory, there is a complete performance of ALL six Haydn quartets here. The players are usually the Hagen Quartet of Salzburg, Austria (Mozart's birthplace), though the players for #17 are different.  The recording is in places less than it could have been [beware, there's an annoying break in the recording at 1:46:10 to 1:50 obliterating the last movement of #17.  it resumes beginning #18], but some of the spaces where they play are beautiful and the performances are competent and certainly represent the state of string quartet playing as of their posting; 27 August, 2012.)

The last of these quartets derives its name from its strange dissonant opening Adagio, which presents an emotionally deep musical subject, never treated of again, to be answered as it were by the rest of the Allegro first movement, which is happiness itself, to sheer joy, simply one of the most sparkling of Mozart's many achievements. Therefore,

String Quartet # 19 in C major ("Dissonance"), K. 465
1. Adagio-Allegro
2. Andante cantabile - in F major 
3. Menuetto. Allegro. (C major, trio in C minor)
4. Allegro molto

This performance is by the Gewandhaus Quartet (Leipzig, Germany of course. They also bill themselves as the oldest continuously organized string quartet in the world. Well!) and I suppose this glorious performance took place sometime before 29 September, 2010. These players really know this music. Note too the room in which they are playing. The year it was written was 1782. The American Revolution was over, except for the settlement of debts and the horrible inflation of a government issued money called the “continental” which failed and ruined many. Meanwhile in Europe, as they decided things, many of the diplomats might have been treated to these as they were possibly the equal of today's overnight hits among the select “in crowd” in fashionable places like London, Paris or even Berlin and St. Petersburg. Franklin and Jefferson were known to have corresponded with Mozart and were keenly interested in such things as string quartets. Listen with pause to the grim realities hinted at in the Andante cantabile. Yes, while there is confidence and hope, these realities are yet to be dealt with. The subject of the third movement, the minuet, has always surprised me. Its origins are probably deeply ethnic, but in the hands of a Mozart they are rendered into peerless fine art. The trio of this movement is in the minor, a reminder of that darker side of life. Pairing the two qualities in this movement makes this one of the greatest dance movements in all music. I really wouldn't say such things if they weren't quite possibly true. The finale is a tribute to Papa Haydn, who might as have written such things himself. But this is unmistakeably Mozart in so many ways that it stands forth as a gratuitous monument to the little man who took his musical dictations directly from God. 

The “Hoffmeister”

String Quartet #20 in D Major, K. 499 “Hoffmeister”
I. Allegretto, in D major
II. Menuetto: Allegretto, in D major, with a trio section in D minor
III. Adagio, in G major
IV. Allegro, in D major

This one, #20 began our survey. It is the only one other than #1, the “Lodi,” that stands by itself. There's so much here already, that I've decided to let you discover the best performances you can of this one, but just to say that this one is by itself rather special and rewards those who get it.

The Prussian Quartets

These are the last three Mozart string quartets. These presage Beethoven right from the beginning. You should have little difficulty hearing the connections. They acquired their name as they were written for and dedicated to the King of Prussia, Friedrich Wilhelm II, between 1789 and 1790. By 1790, Mozart had only one year left and that same year, Papa Haydn was to be fetched away to London to enjoy his great success. By the time he returned to Vienna, Mozart was gone. Had Mozart somehow been able to go away with Haydn, musical history may have been changed dramatically, but such are the weird and sad events of history and the fate of mere mortal men. Life is short, art is long!

String Quartet #21 in D Major, K. 575 “The Violet”
I. Allegretto
II. Andante
III. Menuetto: Allegretto
IV. Allegretto

Again, we are fortunate to have the superb Gewandhaus Quartet for this masterful performance, which took place sometime prior to its posting on 15 October, 2010. In the case of names for classical music pieces, this piece comes by its nickname, “The Violet,” quite honestly as the second movement is based on a song by the same name, Das Vielchen, written by Mozart back in 1785.

Thank-you for coming along on this tour of some of the greatest music ever written. May your searches for competent live performances of these masterpieces be rewarded !

FINIS

Thursday, May 2, 2013

Richard Goode – Beethoven, the Last 3 Sonatas


Last night (1 May, 2013), the veteran concert pianist, Richard Goode (69) played the last three Beethoven piano sonatas in a concert at Carnegie Hall. Here's how his performances might have sounded. We never know for how long, but while YouTube lasts, here are three gems of the piano repertoire played for both emotional and intellectual edification by one of the greatest pianists of his generation.

Sonata #30 in E Major, Op. 109
Sonata #31 in A flat Major, Op. 110
Sonata #32 in c minor, Op. 111 

By the way, for the time being, ALL of Goode's performances of Beethoven sonatas are available for listening on YouTube.  Please remember though that while they are alive and working, all musicians change their interpretations somewhat and whether they be someone of Goode's stature or not, all musicians need to support themselves through patronage.  Please try to attend their live concerts and consider the purchase of their CD's as gifts.  Thank-you.